Showing posts with label public opinion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label public opinion. Show all posts

Monday, 27 April 2015

You shall not pass

 “There is a hidden agenda in the fragility of romance”. 


– Alexander McQueen
Agenda setting
I talked about the spiral of silence theory in the previous entry and stated that media played an important role in it. But how do media influence public opinion exactly? This question is answered thanks to the agenda setting theory, developed by Max McCombs and Donald Shaw. Having taken a few courses related to journalism, I was familiar with the concepts of agenda settings and gatekeepers, but until I took this class I hadn’t really thought of them as part of a theory. For me, gatekeepers and agendas were elements that just exist in media because every medium –and every person– has different interests, opinions and approaches.  I had all the pieces of the puzzle but never stopped to put them all together.

The two main assumptions of McCombs’ and Shaw’s agenda setting theory were: on the one hand, media don’t reflect reality, they filter and shape it; and on the other hand, media concentration on certain subjects leads the audience to regard them as more important. In short, and as I said in my previous entry, media tells the public what to think about. 

Agenda setting theory. Source: mctheory.wordpress.com

During the 1968 presidential election, McCombs and Shaw conducted a study between 100 residents of Chapel Hill (North Carolina) to demonstrate their theory. They compared the public's perceptions of which was the most important election issue with the issues featured in local and national media, and proved a strong correlation between both. Linking this with the spiral of silence theory again, we can see how the events and opinions that appear in media are seen as most important or “the majority”, and everything else –“the minority”– is shadowed and eventually will lose more support.

In class, we saw and discussed a recent example of agenda settings: the Ebola birus. News about Ebola virus started appearing significantly in western media during summer in 2014. People in Guinea, Liberia or Sierra Leone keep getting infected by the virus and dying, but they no longer appear in media because the outbreak in western/northern countries has been eradicated. It's not a threat for us anymore, so it's regarded as something not important.

Gatekeepers
So how exactly are these agendas set up? First, there are “compelling news events”: stories or issues that are generally viewed as public interest. There’s no hidden agenda behind showcasing those news, although the agenda might affect the approach given. And second, agendas are set through gatekeepers, agents who decide if a message will be distributed by a medium or not.


Picture the iconic scene of Gandalf standing in Durin's Bridge fighting the Baldrog. That bridge was described as so narrow that it had to be crossed in single file line, allowing the dwarven defenders to quickly undermine the enemy forces. Now let’s put both scenarios together, with Gandalf and the dwarves at the same time: they’ll be the gatekeepers. Every single story must cross the bridge to appear in the medium, but it won’t be a walk in the park. There will be dozens of dwarves, each with different opinions and interests, examining the story and shooting arrows at it if they don’t think it should be featured in the medium. And at the end of the bridge, Gandalf will have the final decision on whether the story shall or shall not pass.

Scene from LOTR: The Fellowship of the Ring. Source: tumblr.com

In this particular scenario, the role of Gandalf will be played by media owners and editors, and among the dwarves there will be a variety of groups: journalists, Government, advertisers, lobbies, and even things as basic as media formats and working routines.

Framing news
As I anticipated, there is another way of enforcing agendas: choosing the approach or, more specifically, framing the news. I found an example of this phenomenon in October 2013 for another class project, and it illustrates perfectly how news can be framed. 

The 5th of October of 2013, there was a protest in Bilbao in favour of Herrira, an organisation that supported the rights of Basque prisoners. While Gara, a diary that is known for sympathising with Basque independence, focused on the goals of the protest and support that it obtained, La Razón, a diary known for having a strong right-wing ideology, focused on political parties and figures who attended the protest and made allusions to the terrorist group ETA.

Left: Gara, 6th October 2013. Right: La Razóm, 6th October 2013.
The headlines read: “65,000 protesters take the baton of Herrira in Bilbao” – Gara; and “Bildu defies Justice after the police hit on Herrira” – La Razón.

Audience and algorithms
There’s also a very important gatekeeper that I haven’t mentioned yet: the audience. If a certain content works well, has a good audience, there will be more; if the audience doesn’t respond very well, though, it will be discontinued. In addition, with the new technologies and social networks, the public has the chance to take more control. The Internet has two characteristics that encourage users to talk about more topics, even less popular ones. On the one hand, anonymity usually counteracts the fear of isolation mentioned in the theory of the spiral of silence. Being anonymous can translate into feeling more freedom to express unpopular opinions. On the other hand, now not only journalists get articles and opinions published; anybody can start a blog or simply speak in social networks about topics that don’t get coverage in other media.

And speaking of new technologies, search engines have gained importance as a source of information. These engines, such as Google, use their own algorithms to filter information and decide what’s more relevant; they have their own gatekeepers too. As an activity, in class we run various searchs in Google and compared the results we found in the first page. We googled several politicians and other celebrities and in all cases the first results were their official site, their Twitter accounts, Wikipedia articles, recent news in important diaries and IMDb articles (in the case of actors and actresses). These are the sites where users usually go for information about famous people, so perhaps the public has a certain influence or weigh in these algorithms as well.

Wednesday, 11 March 2015

A naked emperor and a dancing guy

“Half the world is composed of people who have something to say and can't, and the other half who have nothing to say and keep on saying it”.

– Robert Frost

Public opinion
In the last entry I spoke about mass communication and why nowadays we talk simply about media and don’t use the term “mass media” anymore. Following with that, we ought to wonder when did people’s opinion start to be taken into account. The concept of public opinion is related to the mass and also strongly tied to democracy. The French Revolution and the American Revolutionary War both played an important role in paving the road to democracy, but the biggest step towards paying attention to the people’s thoughts was only possible thanks to mass media.

There might be a significant difference between what we think others think and what they really think, though. There’s where the concept of perceived public opinion comes on the scene. We can never be sure of what others think, but we do have a perception of what we think is the majority’s opinion. When we think that our own personal beliefs don’t match the majority’s view we might be less likely to voice our thoughts.


Spiral of silence
That fear of expressing an opinion that is perceived as a minority was first explained by Elizabeth Noelle-Nuemann in her theory of the spiral of silence. She explained the phenomenon of the spiral of silence in the context of the Nazi Germany. But long before that, there have been plenty of examples of this occurrence in history, both in everyday life and in popular culture.

One of the most notorious ones is in the tale The Emperor’s New Clothes by Hans Christian Andersen. In that story, the emperor walks in a parade wearing a suit that was, supposedly, invisible for anyone who was “stupid or incompetent”. The emperor had been tricked and was actually naked, but nobody dares to say the truth fearing they will be considered stupid or incompetent. In the end, a little boy speaks up and screams “He’s naked!” and only then the public loses the fear and voices their true opinion.


The spiral of silence, therefore, takes place when individuals think their point of view is a minority and censor themselves because they’re afraid of being isolated. This happens especially when one thinks their opinion will lose more support in the future. The ones who think are a majority punish this minority and try to silence them. When people with similar opinions don’t voice them, the idea loses more support and it will continue to be perceived as a minority.



Spiral of silence. Source: www.comindwork.com

As can be seen in the picture above, media has a significant role in this incident. Media tells people, if not what to think, what to think about. Media expresses views that are usually considered as the opinions of the majority. If one’s opinion is not on the media, then one will probably think that the majority thinks differently. That’s why representation, objectivity, diversity and independence are so important in media, in order not to keep the spiral of silence alive and going. And those are goals that I, as a student in the field of Communication, expect to contribute to as well.

Breaking the silence
There are two ways of breaking the spiral of silence, or two kinds of people who break it: on the one hand, hardcore nonconformists, who have very strong opinions and values and don’t get influenced by the majority’s opinion; and, on the other hand, avant garde visionaries, the first ones who dare to speak up. In the tale of the emperor, even when the kid is the first one who speaks up, we can’t consider him an avant garde visionary. He speaks up not because he’s a visionary, but because he isn’t concerned about the public opinion, what makes him rather a nonconformist.


There have been numerous cases of thinkers and scientists who have had to kneel down before the Church (majority) and retract of their progressive thoughts. It is wide known the case of Galileo Galilei, who was forced to say that the Earth didn’t actually spin around the Sun. It’s said that at the end he added “eppur si muove” (“and yet it moves”), referring to our planet. It’s uncertain whether he really said those words, but I personally find it nice to believe so. That would make him both a visionary, for thoroughly explaining the movement of the Earth and the Sun for the first time, and quite a nonconformist too.

Another interesting case is Michel de Montaigne, an important philosopher of the French Renaissance (thanks to my History of Political Thinking class for this input!). He was a skeptical and thought that cultures, ideas and religions were neither true nor false; they were just superstitions for him. But at the same time, he was a conformist and advised not to voice opinions contrary to the beliefs of the majority because that could be dangerous. Of course, that was said in a time when Inquisition was in full force in Europe, but he was still contributing to the spiral of silence – 400 years before that theory was even formulated!

Here’s a video we watched during the lecture that explains how the spiral of silence can be broken by an avant garde visionary:




Silence in the Basque Country
Anthony T. Spencer and Stephen M. Croucher carried out a study about the spiral of silence regarding the Basque terrorist organization ETA[1]. They found out that, although neither French, Spanish nor Basque respondents had a good opinion about ETA, French and Spanish residents were less likely to voice their opinion in front of Basque residents. They also discovered that Spanish residents outside the Basque Country had the most unfavorable opinion of ETA, while French residents had the least unfavorable opinion.

They conclude that, since Spanish residents live closer to the violence than French residents, the fear of isolation and therefore the effect of the spiral of silence is stronger in Spain than in France. That spiral of silence happens especially in front of Basque residents, mainly because ETA is part of the Basque group.




[1] Anthony T. Spencer and Stephen M. Croucher; Basque Nationalism and the Spiral of Silence: An Analysis of Public Perceptions of ETA in Spain and France; International Communication Gazette 2008; 70; 137; DOI: 10.1177/1748048507086909